Scalloped Button Tabs, Early 1930s

Scallop-shaped button tabs from 1930. Sometimes they are bound with bias tape. The ones on the left may be topstitched, instead.

Sometimes a minor fashion detail will catch my eye as I browse through photos. I don’t think this one was a major fashion trend, but it does show up enough for me to make quite a collection of examples. Scalloped hems had been seen in the 1920s, but these button tabs seem to be a 1929  – 1931 feature. They are shown on women and children.

Scalloped button tabs on a woman’s tunic and a girl’s dress. Butterick patterns, 1930.

Sometimes they appear on skirts.

Scalloped button tabs on suit skirts. 1930 and 1931.

Sometimes they are bound with bias fabric contrasting with the dress; sometimes they are lined but not outlined. See above. (And sometimes it’s had to tell which from the illustrations….)

Scallops are a theme on the collar and button tabs of this dress from October 1930.

I think the dark outline of the scallops is not bias binding, but the artist’s attempt to show a shadow. The tabs on the skirt hold a pleat in place. They probably don’t unbutton.

A “tailored” wool dress. “Like many this season, it’s a buttoned frock with scallops used smartly.”

I’m not sure how popular bias-bound scalloped button tabs would have been with home stitchers…. It’s relatively easy to make a scalloped edge when it is finished with the garment’s lining, like the hem of this blue dress:

The blue dress on the left has a scalloped hem lined with gray taffeta. Butterick pattern from 1926.

Aprons and cotton dresses often had scalloped hems bound with contrasting bias tape.

Left: A day dress from 1929 has scallops at the waist, the collar, and the hem. The hem appears to be bound with bias tape.

This apron from 1931 uses bias tape for trim and to bind the edges of hem, neckline, armholes and waist ties.

A scalloped apron hem bound with bias tape. 1931.

The curved part of the scallop is easy to bind, but the points where the curves meet take some practice.

Scalloped button tabs appeared in Delineator in November, 1929:

Scalloped button tabs on a blouse and skirt, Butterick 2916. November 1929.

The blouse and skirt on the left, Butterick 2916, was illustrated on two pages of Delineator, November 1929. Note the natural waist (a new fashion) and the  knee-length hems (about to go out of style.)

There are subtle differences, like the color of the attached scarf and the size of the buttons.

Two versions of Butterick 2916. 1929. The blouse tucks into the skirt, which has matching scallops.

Two big scalloped button tabs on Sport dress 3257. June 1930. Bias binding adds a dash of color.

It’s likely that many of these scalloped button tabs were purely decorative, and the dresses opened under the arm, along the side seam.

Scallops showed up on house dresses…

Scalloped button tabs on a cotton wash dress. 1930.

And on suits…

A series of rounded button tabs on this suit are not actually scallops. The text commented on the natural waist of this suit. Butterick 3151, April 1930.

Scallops had long been popular on girls’ clothes.

Dresses for schoolgirls, 1930.

Scalloped button tabs make this simple coat very fancy. October 1930.

The next illustration gives us a combination of scallops and straight lines! Probably artistic license….

One armhole and one side of the neckline have scallops. The buttons have scalloped tabs. Illustration for an article on sportswear, Delineator, May 1930.

Occasionally the button tabs took on an angular, zig-zag quality:

Pointed button tabs instead of curved ones — a little variety. Left, 1930; right, 1929.

This stylish scalloped version comes from December, 1931:

Butterick 4231, Delineator, December 1931.

That’s all, folks!

13 Comments

Filed under 1920s, 1920s-1930s, 1930s, Children's Vintage styles, Coats, Sportswear, Vintage Styles in Larger Sizes

13 responses to “Scalloped Button Tabs, Early 1930s

  1. Linda - Yéyé Dolls

    I collect old and antique photographs and have seen this occasionally, and also the zigzag version. I love this style with scallops. It’s a simple way to make a frock very elegant! Again a very interesting article, thank you for sharing!

  2. This is a beautiful detail! However, I think that the scallops have to be absolutely uniform to look good–that would be hard for me to pull off!

    • One thing I learned from watching “next great designer” TV shows was that there’s economic pressure to eliminate pockets and anything else that adds to construction time. So, let’s save the scallops for very special projects. Things we can’t get in stores….

  3. Just watched an old episode of Great British Sewing Bee where someone added scallops to a dress and comment was made that it was tricky to get them even, particularly as they weren’t deeply scalloped. Your post was perfectly timed!

    • They do take patience. I can’t imagine doing them as part of a four hour project! Just watched a episode this week. The time limit is ridiculous, so the results were not inspiring to me! On the other hand, since I know nothing about making pottery, I love the Great Pottery throwdown shows.

      • Have been skipping around through the years of GBSB and there’s such a difference. Last night watched a Season 2 with a challenge to add 2 pockets to a wool A-line skirt. In Season 4 they’re bra-making.
        There’s a pottery show?? Wanna find that one!

      • Making bras?! That’s structural engineering. Even my husband watches the Great Pottery Throwdown with me. He likes the supportive atmosphere: the competitors are nice to each other! I appreciate learning the vocabulary and techniques, because I’ve always been interested in archaeology. Finally, being able to identify and date potsherds by the “slip,” the glaze, and the construction is making sense. I’ve also been watching Richard Hemery, an archeologist who is also a potter, identifying bits of history found in the Thames….

      • GBSB sounds much the same, being a supportive group of not-really-competitors. Have gotten to the last 3 shows of season 4 and everyone stands with hands clasped/arms around waists as the person leaving is announced. Then everyone hugs, cries, and they say how much they’ve learnt and loved getting to know everyone.
        Will follow your links and keep fingers crossed that we are allowed to watch the pottery program over here, across the pond.
        Thank you!

  4. Mary B.

    I am so excited to see these specific 1930 fashions as they are hard to come by. I need to come up with a period ensemble to wear for our Model A Ford outings and they have to be specific to the year one’s car is. Thank you, thank you. I love reading your posts, no matter what era as they are so informative. Thank you.

    • Thank you. It’s good to know you find my “collections” of little fashion details have a practical use. I appreciate the loving work that goes into vintage car rallies, especially since my favorite mechanic mentioned that our modern dependence on computerized parts makes it unlikely that the cars of today will be able to be perfectly restored 50 years from now.

  5. This is a great tip to add to my “Useful details for dating garments” file.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.